Once your PRO trial is over you can continue using Landlord Studio GO completely free.
By continuing you agree to our Terms & Conditions.
Please visit our United Kingdom site for a better experience
ContinueLearn about pet screening for landlords and tenants, including legal considerations, best practices, and how to manage risks while expanding your applicant pool.
.jpg)
According to the American Pet Products Association (APPA), there has been a rising trend in pet ownership among renters in the United States (US). Reports from APPA’s National Pet Owners Survey show that nearly 67% of U.S. households own a pet.
For landlords, this means welcoming tenants with pets will be crucial to expanding their applicant pool and increasing rental income. Yet, we know the potential risks that come with it, from property damage to liability issues.
Pet screening is a critical tool for managing these risks while maintaining a tenant‑friendly approach. Unlike standard tenant screening, which focuses on credit history, income verification, and rental references, pet screening evaluates the potential risks associated with a tenant’s animal.
Landlords assess factors such as the pet’s breed, size, age, vaccination status, and behavior history. These assessments help ensure that pets do not compromise property conditions, the safety of other residents, or compliance with insurance requirements.
This article explores the mechanisms, legal considerations, and best practices for both landlords and tenants engaging in pet screening, providing actionable insights for informed decision‑making.
Related Article: The Fair Housing Act and Emotional Support Animals
Pet screening is a structured process that evaluates a tenant’s pet before granting approval to live in a rental property. While traditional tenant screening focuses on financial and behavioral reliability, pet screening examines the potential risks and responsibilities associated with the animal itself.
Key elements typically considered in pet screening include breed, size, age, vaccination history, and documented behavioral traits.
Some landlords also request references from previous landlords or veterinarians to gauge the pet’s temperament and prior history. The goal is not to exclude pet owners arbitrarily but to identify potential issues that could affect property safety, landlord insurance coverage, or the well-being of other tenants.
Modern pet screening often relies on third-party services that provide standardized assessments, including liability scoring and verification of vaccination or license records. These platforms can generate detailed reports summarizing the pet’s risk profile, which landlords can use to make informed leasing decisions.
Pet screening operates within a framework of legal obligations designed to protect both landlords and tenants.
Fair Housing Act (FHA) requires landlords to make reasonable accommodations for service animals and emotional support animals (ESAs), even under no-pet policies. Landlords must differentiate between ordinary pets and legally protected animals. While standard pets can be subject to breed or size restrictions, service animals and ESAs are exempt from such limitations.
Requesting documentation for ESAs is permitted, but landlords cannot demand medical records beyond verification of need. Misclassification or refusal to accommodate can result in legal liability.
Pet-related charges vary significantly by jurisdiction. Some states prohibit or cap pet deposits, restrict monthly pet fees, or limit total security deposits. California, for example, caps combined security deposits based on unit type, while other states regulate refundability and application of pet-related charges.
Landlords must verify state-specific regulations before implementing pet fees or deposits. For guidance on local requirements, consult Landlord Studio's state law resources.
Insurance policies may restrict coverage for certain breeds or animals with behavioral histories. Pet screening identifies these risks before lease execution. Landlords should apply screening criteria consistently to all applicants, establishing transparent policies on weight limits, vaccinations, and behavioral expectations to reduce disputes and ensure defensible practices.
Read also: Can you Charge a Pet Deposit in California?
.jpg)
Implementing effective pet screening requires a structured approach that balances tenant appeal with property protection. Landlords can follow several best practices to streamline the process and mitigate potential risks.
The first step is defining a detailed pet policy. This should outline acceptable pet types, weight and size limits, breed restrictions, vaccination requirements, and behavioral expectations. Including these details in the lease or a dedicated pet addendum ensures transparency and provides a legal reference in case of disputes.
Clear policies also help tenants understand the requirements before submitting an application, reducing the likelihood of disagreements later.
Third-party pet screening services offer standardized assessments, including verification of vaccinations, licenses, and liability history. These tools often provide a risk score, helping landlords make informed decisions without relying solely on subjective judgment.
Landlords should assess the potential risks associated with each pet relative to the rental property’s characteristics. Factors such as unit size, shared common areas, and proximity to other tenants can influence acceptable pet types.
Balancing risk with the benefits of attracting responsible pet owners—who often stay longer and pay higher deposits—can optimize both tenant satisfaction and financial outcomes.
A well-structured lease agreement or pet addendum should reference the screening process, including any required documentation and the consequences of noncompliance. By integrating pet screening into lease terms, landlords create clear expectations for tenants, establish enforceable standards, and reduce disputes over pet-related issues.
Finally, landlords should regularly review their pet screening practices to reflect changes in local regulations, insurance requirements, and industry standards. Periodic updates help maintain compliance, protect the property, and foster a positive rental experience for both pets and tenants.
Read also: How To Set The Best Landlord Pet Policy
For tenants, preparing for pet screening can significantly increase the likelihood of rental approval while demonstrating responsibility as a pet owner. Understanding what landlords look for and presenting relevant documentation are key strategies.
Tenants should gather and organize essential records for their pets. This typically includes vaccination certificates, license information, spay/neuter documentation, and any training or behavioral certifications.
Some landlords also request references from previous landlords or veterinarians, which can provide evidence of good behavior and responsible ownership.
A pet resume is a concise summary that highlights the animal’s key attributes, such as age, breed, training history, temperament, and prior living situations. Including photos, certifications, and references adds credibility. This tool not only streamlines the screening process but also demonstrates proactive engagement and accountability.
Before submitting an application, tenants should review the property’s pet policies thoroughly. Awareness of breed restrictions, weight limits, deposit requirements, and additional fees helps prevent misunderstandings. Tenants can also negotiate minor accommodations or clarifications, particularly if the pet is well-behaved and fully documented.
Open communication with landlords about the pet’s history, habits, and care routine can reduce concerns. Providing assurance regarding supervision, training, and preventative measures (like flea control or crate training) fosters trust and positions the tenant as reliable.
Even after approval, tenants should continue to demonstrate responsible ownership. Timely vaccinations, obedience training, and proper waste management not only protect the property but also preserve a positive relationship with the landlord and neighbors.
By approaching pet screening with preparation, transparency, and proactive documentation, tenants can secure approval efficiently while maintaining a positive rental experience for themselves and their pets.
While pet screening helps manage potential issues, both landlords and tenants face challenges and trade-offs when integrating pets into rental properties. Understanding these dynamics is essential for informed decision-making.
One of the most immediate concerns for landlords is potential property damage. Pets can scratch floors, chew furniture, or cause stains, leading to repair costs that may exceed typical wear and tear. Even with deposits in place, assessing damage and managing repairs can be time-consuming and costly.
Pets, particularly dogs, can create noise disturbances affecting other tenants. Complaints about barking or other disruptive behavior may require landlords to intervene, potentially straining tenant relationships. Screening helps mitigate risk, but no process can fully eliminate behavioral issues.
Certain insurance policies impose restrictions on specific breeds or animals with a history of aggression. Liability claims can arise if a pet injures a visitor or another tenant. Proper screening ensures that landlords are aware of these risks and can adjust coverage or implement mitigation strategies.
Pet-friendly policies can attract a wider applicant pool, foster tenant retention, and increase rental income. However, welcoming pets inherently increases exposure to potential problems. Landlords must weigh the benefits against costs and risks, adopting strategies like breed restrictions, pet deposits, or liability waivers to maintain equilibrium.
Even with thorough pet screening, unexpected issues can occur. Behavioral problems may develop over time, and third-party assessments cannot predict all outcomes. Tenants may also fail to disclose relevant information, emphasizing the need for ongoing monitoring and clear lease terms.
For tenants, adhering to screening requirements may involve extra effort, documentation, and potential fees. Some properties may impose restrictions or additional deposits, which can affect housing choices. However, compliance demonstrates responsible ownership and enhances the likelihood of securing a desirable rental.
.jpg)
Pet screening is a strategic tool that balances risk management with market opportunity. When implemented systematically, it protects property interests while expanding rental options for pet-owning tenants.
Effective pet screening requires clear policies, consistent documentation, and ongoing compliance monitoring. Landlord Studio offers integrated property management tools to streamline pet screening documentation, track deposits, and maintain comprehensive tenant records.
Key Takeaways:
By treating pet screening as a core component of tenant management, landlords can build more inclusive rental portfolios while maintaining operational standards. Visit Landlord Studio to explore resources and tools designed for modern property management.
What is pet screening for rentals?
Pet screening evaluates a tenant’s pet to assess potential risks, including behavior, breed, size, age, and vaccination status, helping landlords make informed leasing decisions.
Are landlords allowed to restrict certain pet breeds?
Yes, landlords may impose breed or size restrictions, provided they comply with insurance requirements and do not violate laws regarding service or emotional support animals.
Can tenants submit documentation to improve approval chances?
Absolutely. Providing vaccination records, a pet resume, behavioral references, and veterinary information can demonstrate responsibility and streamline the screening process.
Are emotional support animals exempt from pet policies?
Yes. Service animals and emotional support animals are legally protected and must be accommodated under the Fair Housing Act, even if the property has a no-pet policy.
What risks do landlords face if they allow pets?
Common risks include property damage, noise complaints, liability for injuries, and potential insurance limitations. Screening and clear policies help mitigate these risks.
How can landlords balance pet-friendly policies with risk management?
Implementing clear rules, deposits, third-party screening, and consistent enforcement allows landlords to welcome pets while protecting property and tenants.
Landlord Studio is an easy to use property management and accounting software designed for landlords.
Find and screen tenants, collect rent online, track income and expenses, run reports, and more - all for free.
Maximize your rental property tax deductions and file with confidence before the deadline with property management accounting software designed for you.
Hosted by: Logan Ransley, Co-founder of Landlord Studio
From finding tenants to filing taxes. Reduce vacancies and maximize your portfolio ROI with software designed for you.
Get started for free
.jpg)
